Search hotels in Shelter Island
Enter your dates to see the latest prices and deals for Shelter Island hotels
Filter by:
Star Rating
Review Score
The Pridwin Hotel
The Pridwin is a waterfront resort located on Shelter Island with 33 well-appointed guest rooms and 16 private cottages an all-American restaurant and lively lounge with water views a full service...
Rams Head Inn
Rams Head Inn features a garden, terrace, a restaurant and bar in Shelter Island. Among the various facilities are water sports facilities and a private beach area.
Sound View Greenport
Set on the North Fork in Greenport, 98 mi from New York City, Sound View Greenport features a seasonal outdoor pool and views of the Long Island Sound. Guests can enjoy a drink at the bar.
The Harbor Front Inn
Offering a seasonal outdoor swimming pool and a fitness center, The Harbor Front Inn is centrally located near the shops and restaurants in Greenport. Free WiFi access is available.
Baron's Cove
Featuring an on-site restaurant and seasonal saltwater swimming pool, Baron's Cove is located in Sag Harbor, New York.
American Beech Hotel
American Beech Hotel has free bikes, garden, a restaurant and bar in Greenport. This 4-star hotel offers free WiFi. The property is allergy-free throughout and is located 26 miles from Splish Splash.
The Menhaden Hotel
Located 26 miles from Splish Splash, The Menhaden Hotel in Greenport has a terrace and bar.
Hotel Moraine
Located in Greenport, 24 miles from Splish Splash, Hotel Moraine provides accommodations with free bikes, free private parking, a seasonal outdoor swimming pool and a fitness center.
Silver Sands Motel & Beach Bungalows
Located in Greenport, 25 miles from Splish Splash, Silver Sands Motel & Beach Bungalows has accommodations with free bikes, free private parking, a garden and a restaurant.
The Shoals Suites & Slips
The Shoals Suites & Slips is offering accommodations in Southold. This 4-star hotel has air-conditioned rooms with a private bathroom. Parking is free for guests, there is no extra charge.
Explore guest reviews of hotels in Shelter Island
- 8.9Scored 8.9ExcellentRated excellent· 61 reviewsOverall property is nice. It's a small island so getting to and from Points of Interest from the Pridwin as as hub is a convenience. We also came across the Chequit hotel, and ended up having a lunch there, so no regrets electing Pridwin. The views from the hotel bar and restaurant are enchanting. FYI the Pridwin is recently acquired under new management. This was my first time, but just an FYI to future guests.
WallaceUnited States of America - 8.9Scored 8.9ExcellentRated excellent· 61 reviewsLocation is beautiful and charming. The hotel decor is beautiful, tastefully done, so charming, and high quality. My room was simple but very nicely appointed, immaculate, and bed was comfortable. Cocktails, dinner, and breakfast were superior! My dinner entree was really top notch in both flavor and presentation. All staff were very professional and extremely courteous.AnneUnited States of America
- 8.9Scored 8.9ExcellentRated excellent· 61 reviewsThe hotel was gorgeous. The staff was professional and very accomadating. The rooms lovely. Brand new. The view stunning. The grouds and pool and terrace, etc... I got a complimentary breakfast and boat ride (which they dont advertise) and a yoga class. They had music.
LisaUnited States of America - 9.9Scored 9.9ExceptionalRated exceptional· 24 reviewsWe had an amazing stay at Seven. Beth and Patrick are very accommodating and friendly. Seven has everything you need for a great stay at Shelter Island. We really liked the pool, gym area and breakfast.
MarjanNetherlands - 8.9Scored 8.9ExcellentRated excellent· 61 reviewsLovely hotel, right on the water with a (very) little beach across the street on the water, paddle boards and kayaks, quaint room, amazing breakfast included, s;mores at night, great views and sunsets!
AmyUnited States of America - From $341.18 per night8.9Scored 8.9ExcellentRated excellent· 8 reviewsThe staff was very welcoming and knowledgeable about the area. Beautiful location - we loved being there in the "off season" and getting to experience Shelter Island w/o the summer crowd.NicodemusUnited States of America
- From $341.18 per night8.9Scored 8.9ExcellentRated excellent· 8 reviewsThe dining area was very warm and inviting. Its very tres chic. In love withthe nautical/tropical vibe of the furnishing. Really compliments the Inn’s impeccable tasteMariaUnited States of America
- From $341.18 per night8.9Scored 8.9ExcellentRated excellent· 8 reviewsQuiet, beautiful, great food, wonderful staff. We even got to meet the owner and hear more about her vision for the hotel - one which we strongly support.MichaelUnited States of America
- 8.9Scored 8.9ExcellentRated excellent· 61 reviewsThe hotel is well designed, furnished, landscaped and is very clean
CliffordUnited States of America - 8.9Scored 8.9ExcellentRated excellent· 61 reviewsVery pretty hotel and very clean
IsabelleUnited Kingdom
Research, refine, and make plans for your whole trip
